The Moscow government would doubtless issue an ultimatum that Ukraine must not infringe into areas of Donbas under Russian control before 24 February and, above all, that it must not enter the Crimean Peninsula. That is when things start to get difficult. A fast advance would test Ukrainian logistics, but within a few days Ukraine would have recovered all the territory lost since 24 February 2022. Like the British Army in August 1918, they can suddenly advance 20 miles instead of 20 yards in a day. Imagine the scene as Ukrainian forces suddenly find there is no resistance in front of them as Russian troops retreat in disarray.

However, in reality, a mutiny would entail a few days of very significant risk. The sudden evacuation of the Kharkiv area in September bore the hallmarks of a rout, with troops abandoning their positions in a hurry and leaving equipment and personal effects behind.įor most of us in the West, a wholesale Russian collapse would be a cause for celebration, heralding a rapid end to the war and an alleviation of some of the economic effects which the conflict has engendered – in particular high energy and food costs. There has already been some evidence of near-mutiny.

Is it really for the Russian nation or for the political survival of Vladimir Putin? Furthermore, the hastily recruited and partly trained conscripts will soon experience the delta between their old Soviet-era equipment and the inventiveness with which Ukraine has integrated commercial drones and satellite imagery with precision artillery fire. There may still be some Russian soldiers who believe their president’s myth about Ukraine being a Nazi state, but increasingly they must wonder why they are enduring considerable risk and awful conditions. It just evaporated because the troops no longer believed in the war as the US negotiated a deal with the Taliban behind the back of their own deeply corrupt government. By contrast, the Afghan army did not exactly mutiny in July and August 2021. In both cases the troops believed in the need to win the war and knew that it was a national effort involving all strata of society. The British Army on the Western Front in the First World War never mutinied in spite of huge casualties and poor living conditions, and the Russian army endured even worse on the Eastern Front in the Second World War. There is no exact template for mutiny or the sudden disintegration of an army.

Russian navy us civil war